Moscow’s man in Yerevan
In this election, Moscow is all but openly backing Samvel Karapetyan. It was his case that Putin raised during that meeting with Pashinyan, awkwardly saying (mistakenly) that Karapetyan is being held somewhere, whereas he is, in fact, under house arrest.
Karapetyan is a Russian billionaire of Armenian heritage and the founder of the Tashir Group. Forbes estimates his fortune at $3.2 billion. His businesses are everywhere in Yerevan: Tashir Pizza outlets, upscale restaurants, shopping centers. In Moscow, he owns the Rio, Yerevan Plaza and Europark malls.
In other words, he has plenty to lose – whether in a conflict with the Kremlin or with Pashinyan.
A decade ago, Karapetyan’s company was given Electric Networks of Armenia free of charge. Then last year, Armenian authorities announced plans to nationalize the utility – formally over alleged violations, but in reality after Karapetyan publicly challenged Pashinyan during the latter’s confrontation with senior Church figures.
Soon afterward, the billionaire was detained on charges of “public calls to seize power.” Additional accusations of tax evasion and money laundering followed shortly thereafter. Since December, he has been under house arrest, which courts have regularly extended.
During that time, Karapetyan managed to launch the Mer Dzevov (In Our Way) movement and later the Strong Armenia party. According to polling, the party could come in second in the parliamentary election with 13-17% of the vote.
While Karapetyan remains under arrest, his nephew is leading the campaign. The main issue, however, is that despite his popularity, Karapetyan cannot legally become prime minister under Armenian law because he holds dual citizenship. Even if he renounces his Russian citizenship, he will not meet the requirement to have resided in Armenia for at least four years.
The billionaire’s allies insist that they will simply rewrite the law to accommodate him. For now, they have little chance of securing enough seats to amend the constitution, however.
Not even in alliance with Armenia’s third-most-popular political force – former President Robert Kocharyan’s Armenia bloc. That, incidentally, is another weak point for Strong Armenia: neither the party leader nor his deputies particularly enjoy questions about whom they would be willing to join in coalition with. Nobody wants to be associated with Kocharyan – the leader of the so-called Karabakh clan and the central figure in virtually every major corruption scandal in modern Armenian politics.
‘Privet, Rob!’
In September 2001, at Yerevan’s Aragast café (nicknamed Poplavok by Russian speakers), Georgian citizen of Armenian heritage and Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun) member Pogos Pogosyan spotted then-President Kocharyan sitting at a nearby table and disrespectfully called out to him: “privet, Rob!” Minutes later, Pogosyan was found dead in the restroom. Witnesses said Kocharyan’s bodyguards beat him to death – and few in Yerevan doubt they were acting on someone else’s orders.
As astonishing as it may seem, Kocharyan remains active in politics. Polls give him between 4% and 8% support – good enough for third place nationally.
But Kocharyan’s disapproval ratings are equally historic. Armenians remember not only the Poplavok murder, but also the violent dispersal of demonstrations on March 1, 2008, which left almost a dozen dead, along with the staggering corruption under Kocharyan’s rule. It was corruption on such a scale that famed philanthropist Kirk Kerkorian eventually halted his financial support for Armenia and rewrote his will.
Still, the former president retains considerable support among compatriots who relocated to Armenia after defeat in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.
When the Pashinyan-Karapetyan affair was just starting to escalate, Kocharyan dismissed the attacks on the oligarch as “nonsense” and publicly backed the Russian businessman. Soon afterward, a Yerevan court ordered the exhumation of Pogosyan’s body nearly a quarter century after the murder.
That also gave Pashinyan’s team an opening to accuse Karapetyan, Kocharyan and another opposition figure, Gagik Tsarukyan, of forming an alliance with the goal of restarting the war with Azerbaijan.
The accusation sounds dubious. Still, in Yerevan almost nobody holds back from criticizing Pashinyan’s peace deal with Aliyev. The prime minister is attacked for “handing over Karabakh,” improperly demarcating the border allegedly so that Armenian villages end up outside of the country and removing Mount Ararat from Armenian passport stamps at the behest of Turkey.
At the same time, when critics are asked what exactly they would change – Will they put Ararat back on passport stamps? Will they launch a war against Azerbaijan? – straightforward answers are rarely forthcoming.
Most importantly, however, Kocharyan himself has no ambitions of becoming prime minister. Instead, he wants to remain useful to Karapetyan if the latter finishes second and seeks to build a coalition. And that scenario remains entirely plausible.