But the boost for the Russian auto industry from these measures, if one materializes at all, will only be temporary. In April, despite everything mentioned above, AvtoVAZ chief Sokolov regularly
complained that Chinese automakers were taking over the market for new cars in Russia, even
calling for investigations.
Still, his cautious phrasing about the latter likely reflects his lack of confidence about what such investigations would uncover. Putin himself
told Xi on May 8 that the Kremlin expects the Chinese to “create production facilities and transfer Chinese industrial expertise to our country.”
Protectionism is no panaceaDuring the three years of war with Ukraine, Chinese automakers have not opened their own factories in Russia. They have not brought in new technology. They have not even really set up auto part production. Final assembly, metal stamping and electronics adaptation are the maximum the Chinese are willing to do in Russia.
According to NAMI
estimates, as of 2024 the models of the most popular Chinese brand, Haval, which opened a plant in Russia back in 2019, were only 15.1% localized. Why does China need more when it has already increased both exports to Russia and local production at the facilities of exited global automakers and alone has taken almost their entire share of the Russian car market?
The Chinese government, citing risks like secondary sanctions, has
strongly discouraged its automakers from building production capacity in Russia. Chinese automakers operate all over the world and are thus sensitive to the threat of US and European sanctions. Russia is not big enough outweigh these considerations.
But it is not just sanctions. Even if they are lifted, there are still no compelling reasons for China, the world’s largest exporter of cars, to create a full-fledged infrastructure to make cars and car components in Russia. Why would the Chinese want this, when
China today has the capacity to make nearly twice as many cars as its consumers need?
The domestic market in China is the largest in the world, almost as big as the US and European markets combined. Russia has little chance of leveraging protectionist measures to force China to do, in terms of production in Russia, what the brands that exited Russia were doing.
China’s economic domination in Russia at war looks situational, despite all the Kremlin’s talk about a strategic pivot to the East. This year, as soon as hope rose that global brands were about to come back to Russia (many brands still have
options to buy back their facilities in Russia), Russians’ enthusiasm for Chinese cars significantly
cooled off.
Whether this hope proves unfounded or not, China will wait until the end of the war to make strategic decisions.